Tuesday, September 2, 2008
Why does place matter?
In The Writing Life, Dillard has a negative attitude towards place. It seems the place she has chosen to work on her writing traps and confines her. The cabin she writes is not represented in a way that would seem to be feasible to be creative. "It's walls were shrunken planks, not insulated; in January, February and March it was cold." The majority of this piece seems to be focused not on her writing but on her surroundings, even though she states, "I don't much care where I work. I didn't notice things." The place she has chosen to write almost allows her to do anything but write. She tends to just doodle on the pages and not write anything. She even says "I hated to write. I said I would rather do anything else." Place in this piece is very important. The cabin and area where the cabin is located, are desolate places, there seems to be very little happiness or light. These surrounding mimic the writer's attitude toward writing. It isn't until the end of the piece that the reading finally makes sense. Dillard is continually presenting negative, depressing images and when we finally learn that the writer hates writing and does not know why they do it, the pieces seem to fall into place. If this story took place somewhere bright, sunny and warm it would contradict the writer's attitude. That is why place is important because it can change the meaning of the piece and it can help the reader to better understand the piece.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
Annie Dillard's work Writing From the Center was truly interesting in the way that it demonstrated the author's veiws of writing. Clearly, writing is not a peaceful, enjoyable profession, for it demands a person to be isolated, tormented and rarely pleased with the finishing product or the process. In comparing Dillard's work and Sander's, there is a unique take on what role placement takes in the writers' life. Both authors assume that great writing is done in solitude. Only when one is removed from what is familiar and placed in a location that is physically/ emotionally detached from most of civilization can great writing take place. Sanders' seeks his writing success across the world in Europe, while Dillard chooses to work in a remote cabin. In both cases, the author expresses an immense distain for their profession and the prision-like vibe that comes with being a dedicated writer. However, through their journeys, they both come to the conclusion that such placements may bring good writing (or may not) but it comes at a high cost. For Sanders, he discovers that his place is with his family. And for Dillards, I like to think of it this way:
the only time in which she is warm (and I take this to mean figuritively and literally) is when she is OUTSIDE the cabin, chopping the wood. It may be out in the cold, but because she is not isolated to the cabin, she is warm because her soul is warm. Also, during such times she is observed by the islanders-she exists to the world. When she finally learns how to quickly chop wood, even the fire she can produce with it cannot keep her warm.
Place really does matter because it plays a role in our moods, our experiences, our level of comfort and so many other aspects of our lives. Nobody wishes to be in a place that causes unhappiness for them. And for Sanders and Dillard, the importance of place in their lives overlaps into the importance of living.
Post a Comment